
Roberto, the protagonist of Stones in Water (Dutton, 1997), continues his struggle to return to Venice following his escape from a forced labor camp in Nazi-controlled Eastern Europe. Three years have passed and, now 15, he is alone again, having lost both his best friend, who was Jewish, and the Roman deserter who nursed him back from a bullet wound. Apprehended by the Germans, Roberto has escaped yet again, finally reaching the southern portion of Italy aboard an American warship. But his trek back home is jeopardized once more when Nazi bombs force him to jump ship. Once on Italian soil, he continues to move north; is captured by a German soldier who uses him as a translator; and eventually encounters a young woman working in the resistance movement. With her encouragement, the teen learns the intricacies of partisan fighting. Not able to stomach any killing by his own hand, he does his part through the clandestine delivery of ammunition and valuable information. Throughout his ordeal, Robertos humanity and strength of character overshadow the brutality. Napoli extends the reality of his experiences by leaving an open-ended conclusion in which Roberto reaches his beloved Venice unsure, yet hopeful of who and what he will find. Powerful World War II literature.
So I picked this up at the library with my sister on a whim. Was it worth it? I'm still not quite sure. I can't exactly explain how this book made me feel when I read it - and finished it, as well. It was just... different. And sad. Really, really sad.
It was, for some reason suspenseful, even though I didn't really like any of the characters. And despite the abrupt ending and slightly strange characters, I have to give it to Donna Jo Napoli that she knows how to gain attention from her audience.
That would have to be the thing that would give it 3 and a 1/2 stars. If it weren't for that, since it was so darn sad, I would've given it 3 stars. As it was, I'm giving it 3 and a 1/2. Something you can read for the history, but definitely not for a happy story.
No comments:
Post a Comment